Keep Your Friends Close and Our Emails CloserNever miss an episode, plus insider intel we only share with the inner circle.
Episode Archive

Episodes

Stories of crime, psychology, power, identity, and the once-relatable machinery beneath human behavior.

Fraternity Hazing: Dying to Belong
Hive MindEP11

Fraternity Hazing: Dying to Belong

Stone Foltz, Timothy Piazza, Michael Deng and George Desdunes died in cases involving fraternity hazing, each under very different circumstances. What connects them is a harder question: what happens to our sense of right and wrong when belonging, tradition and group loyalty make dangerous behavior feel normal?

Belle Gibson: 'Trust Me, I'm Dying'
Pretty EvilEP10

Belle Gibson: 'Trust Me, I'm Dying'

Belle Gibson had the kind of cancer story people desperately wanted to believe. She said she'd been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer and given months to live. Instead of accepting that prognosis, she changed the way she ate, turned to alternative therapies, and somehow survived. There was just one fairly significant problem: Belle Gibson had never had cancer.

The Monster Study: Authority, Identity & The Stories We Inherit About Ourselves
Under ObservationEP09

The Monster Study: Authority, Identity & The Stories We Inherit About Ourselves

In 1939, University of Iowa graduate student Mary Tudor arrived at the Iowa Soldiers' Orphans' Home with an experiment. Twenty-two children were divided into groups. Some already stuttered. Others spoke normally. Six of those normally speaking children were told something that wasn't true: experts had determined they were developing a speech problem. In this episode of Pretty Evil, we revisit the infamous “Monster Study,” the controversial theory of psychologist Wendell Johnson, the young graduate student who carried it out, and the six children who wouldn't learn the truth about what had happened to them until decades later.

Exorcism of Anneliese Michel: The Original Emily Rose
Failure by DesignEP08

Exorcism of Anneliese Michel: The Original Emily Rose

Anneliese Michel, the young German woman whose story inspired The Exorcism of Emily Rose, died in 1976 after at least 67 exorcism sessions. Some of the recordings still sound deeply unsettling, but the surviving record raises a harder question: why did no one change course as her health collapsed? This episode traces her epilepsy diagnosis, the Church's authorization of the rite, the criminal case, and what happens when a belief takes up so much room that other explanations can't get in. How much room should a belief get when someone's life is at stake?

DeFeo Family Massacre: The Original Amityville Horror
Psychological AutopsyEP07

DeFeo Family Massacre: The Original Amityville Horror

The Amityville Horror is remembered as a haunted-house story, but the darkest thing that happened at 112 Ocean Avenue wasn't supernatural. In November 1974, Ronald DeFeo Jr. killed his parents and four younger siblings in their beds, thirteen months before the Lutz family moved in and fled after 28 days. This episode separates the documented murders from the disputed haunting and asks what we gain by turning a dangerous person inside a family into a dangerous house. What happens to six real victims when their story becomes someone else's prologue?

Elizabeth Holmes & Theranos: The Turtleneck, the Voice, and the $9 Billion Lie
Pretty EvilEP06

Elizabeth Holmes & Theranos: The Turtleneck, the Voice, and the $9 Billion Lie

Theranos promised a full lab panel from a few drops of blood, and for a while the world believed it. Investors valued the company at roughly nine billion dollars, and then the technology, the whistleblowers, and the regulators caught up. This episode walks through the record of what happened, from the Stanford dropout story to the Walgreens rollout to the criminal verdict. Then it asks what the jury couldn't: how does a person build an identity around being extraordinary, and what happens when the evidence stops cooperating? Nathan Fielder's new documentary lets Elizabeth Holmes tell her side, so what should we know before we hear it?

What Is a Delusion? True Crime's Misused Word
Side NotesEP05

What Is a Delusion? True Crime's Misused Word

We call people delusional all the time, and true crime leans on the word just as casually. But clinically, being wrong isn't a delusion, and “the offender was delusional” isn't an explanation. In this first Side Notes episode, we break down what delusions actually are, how they differ from conspiracy beliefs, obsessions, paranoia, and hallucinations, and what the research really says about delusions and violence. What should we listen for when a story calls someone “delusional”?

Richard Chase: The Vampire Of Sacramento
Portrait of a PredatorEP03/EP04

Richard Chase: The Vampire Of Sacramento

Richard Chase is remembered as the Vampire of Sacramento—a man whose crimes shocked investigators, terrified an entire city, and became one of the most infamous cases in FBI profiling history. But what if the most disturbing part of this story isn't what Richard Chase did? What if it's the fact that almost everyone saw it coming? Years before six people were murdered in Sacramento, Chase had been diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, repeatedly hospitalized, and documented exhibiting profoundly disturbing behavior. Nurses feared him. Doctors treated him. Psychiatric staff begged for him to remain hospitalized. Then he was released.

The War On Witches: When Good People Do Evil Things
Hive MindEP02

The War On Witches: When Good People Do Evil Things

Most of us think we already understand the witch hunts. We think of Salem; Of pointed hats, black cats, and women accused of consorting with the devil. It's one of history's most recognizable stories, which is exactly why it's so easy to gloss over. We assume we know what happened, file it away under “historic events in the rearview mirror,” and move on. But the deeper you look, the stranger it gets — and the less it has to do with the Salem we think we know.

Charles Sobhraj & The Psychology of Trust
Pretty EvilEP01

Charles Sobhraj & The Psychology of Trust

When people picture a serial killer, they often imagine someone who immediately feels unsettling. Charles Sobhraj challenges that assumption. Throughout the 1970s, Sobhraj moved effortlessly through the backpacker communities of Southeast Asia, presenting himself as a sophisticated gem dealer, seasoned traveler, and trusted friend. His victims weren't simply chosen at random—they were people who believed they had found someone willing to help them navigate an unfamiliar world. In this episode of Pretty Evil, we explore the psychology behind one of history's most charismatic predators and ask why emotionally intelligent manipulators are often so difficult to recognize.

Robert Hansen & The Coward's Hunt
Coming soon
Portrait of a Predator

Robert Hansen & The Coward's Hunt

Robert Hansen became infamous as Alaska's “Butcher Baker,” a serial killer who abducted women, flew them into the Alaskan wilderness, and hunted them through remote terrain. Or at least that's the mythology. But I think calling what Hansen did a “hunt” gives him far too much credit. He selected women he believed society would be slow to protect. He controlled the weapons, transportation, restraints, terrain, timing, and whether anyone knew where they were. Then, he treated the helplessness he had deliberately manufactured as evidence of his own superiority. But I have a question: What does winning actually prove when you were the person who controlled the rules?