Keep Your Friends Close and Our Emails CloserNever miss an episode, plus insider intel we only share with the inner circle.
Failure by DesignEP08 • 45 mins

Exorcism of Anneliese Michel: The Original Emily Rose

Anneliese Michel, the young German woman whose story inspired The Exorcism of Emily Rose, died in 1976 after at least 67 exorcism sessions. Some of the recordings still sound deeply unsettling, but the surviving record raises a harder question: why did no one change course as her health collapsed? This episode traces her epilepsy diagnosis, the Church's authorization of the rite, the criminal case, and what happens when a belief takes up so much room that other explanations can't get in. How much room should a belief get when someone's life is at stake?

Published October 27, 2026 | Featuring: Jessica Strohm

Listen on Apple Podcasts

What Happened to Anneliese Michel?

Anneliese Michel was a 23-year-old university student from Klingenberg, Bavaria, when she died on July 1, 1976. Over roughly ten months she had undergone at least 67 exorcism sessions, carried out by two Catholic priests with the approval of their bishop. The autopsy reportedly attributed her death to severe malnutrition and dehydration. In 1978, her parents and the two priests were convicted of negligent homicide for failing to get her medical help. Her story later inspired the 2005 film The Exorcism of Emily Rose.

I picked this case from a long list of real-world exorcisms because I reacted to it differently than I usually do. Normally I have a fairly immediate sense of whether I think something is real. But some of the recordings from Anneliese's exorcisms are genuinely unsettling, and I could understand why people hear them and believe something supernatural is going on. Then the more I read about her illness and the decisions made about her care, the harder it became to understand why no one changed course.

So this episode walks through who Anneliese was, the illness that led to the exorcisms, what those sessions involved, and how the medical and spiritual explanations competed for control of her care. It opens, in the episode, with the last day: June 30, 1976, when, according to reporting in the German newspaper taz, she was emaciated, feverish, and still making compulsive kneeling movements as her parents held her up. According to taz, her last words included “Mutter, ich habe Angst”: “Mother, I'm afraid.”

Who Was Anneliese Michel Before the Exorcisms?

Anneliese grew up in a strongly Catholic family in Klingenberg. Her parents were Anna and Josef Michel, and she was the eldest of four sisters. She wanted to become a teacher. After finishing secondary school in 1973, she went to Würzburg to study education and theology, and National Geographic Germany reports that her thesis was about fear and how religious education could help people cope with it. In hindsight, that's an eerie detail.

It's very easy to meet Anneliese through the worst moments of her life: the recordings, the photographs, the film that borrowed her story. That first impression tends to filter everything that comes after. So I wanted to work backward from it, because otherwise it becomes almost impossible to picture her as an ordinary person with plans, and understanding who she was is how we understand what was taken from her.

Her symptoms began years before university. Published accounts place her first major episodes in 1968, when she was a teenager, and a neurologist diagnosed epilepsy. Over time she reportedly described visual and auditory hallucinations, including frightening faces and voices connected to damnation. A neurologist later feared the development of a paranoid psychosis, according to BR24. Reading that as a list of symptoms is very different from imagining it happening to you, where you still have to get through the day, find words for an experience other people can't see, and decide whose diagnosis to trust.

What Medical Care Did Anneliese Michel Receive?

Long before the exorcisms, Anneliese was seeing doctors and taking medication. Published accounts say her treatment included the anti-seizure drugs Tegretol and Dilantin. One case history describes an EEG with an irregular alpha pattern and some theta and delta waves, but nothing pathological, and says the doctor still thought her reported episodes fit epilepsy.

That detail can sound very different depending on how it's presented. Hear that a test showed nothing and you might assume medicine had ruled out an explanation. But today's NICE guidance says not to use an EEG to exclude a diagnosis of epilepsy, because someone can have epilepsy with a normal EEG. (That's modern guidance, not something her doctors would necessarily have known, but it's a useful check on how we read the test.)

This also wasn't a family that never saw a doctor. In a 2015 Deutschlandfunk Kultur interview, historian Petra Ney-Hellmuth, who reviewed the court and police records, said the parents told investigators Anneliese had seen a doctor when she was younger but the medication hadn't worked, which is why they turned to another path. Other reporting adds that the family never accepted the epilepsy diagnosis. I can imagine how frightening and frustrating it is to seek help and watch someone you love keep suffering, and I don't think we have to deny them that to take issue with what they did later.

Unsuccessful treatment can raise real questions about the accuracy of a diagnosis, the effectiveness of a drug, how it was taken, and whether something else was going on at the same time. Current NICE guidance, for example, says to review the diagnosis when seizures continue despite an optimal dose of a first medication. What unsuccessful treatment doesn't do is establish possession.

Could Her Medication Have Played a Role?

I should say up front that I can't answer this, and I haven't found evidence that her medication caused any of what she experienced. But as someone who is sensitive to medication side effects, it was one of the first things I wanted to look at, and it opens possibilities that don't seem to have been investigated.

The prescribing information for Dilantin lists nystagmus (involuntary eye movements), problems with coordination, slurred speech, drowsiness, and mental confusion among its nervous-system effects, and it describes psychosis in connection with high drug levels. Psychosis, according to the National Institute of Mental Health, involves a loss of contact with reality and can include hallucinations like hearing voices. If you're already looking for signs of possession, unusual eye movements or confusion could seem to support that reading. The same label also warns of a rare, serious skin reaction, toxic epidermal necrolysis, which causes blistering and painful, exposed skin and can affect the mouth and throat.

I can't look at photographs of Anneliese's injuries and tell you they were a medication reaction, and I haven't found evidence that she developed that condition. To connect any of this to her case, we'd need clinical records: what she was taking, how much, and what happened when treatment changed. What stays with me is that if someone is having disturbing symptoms during treatment, I'd want to know whether the treatment is part of the problem. If that investigation happened, it didn't make it into the surviving records.

How Did the Church Come to Authorize an Exorcism?

Two priests became central to the story: Father Ernst Alt, who was involved in Anneliese's spiritual care, and Father Arnold Renz, who carried out the major exorcism. In September 1975, Bishop Josef Stangl of Würzburg approved the rite. A letter from the bishop, marked “strictly confidential,” is quoted by BR24. It wasn't only a family member saying this might be spiritual: a bishop had authorized priests to act on that interpretation, which would have lent that explanation enormous weight to her parents.

One episode that fed into the decision was a pilgrimage to San Damiano in Italy. In a review for Skeptical Inquirer, Autumn Sword describes Anneliese saying she couldn't enter the shrine because the ground felt like fire, and notes that religious images became difficult for her to look at. Someone who sees a shrine as sacred might read that as a hostile force. But she was also simply in distress, and whichever explanation you favor, spiritual, physical, or psychological, she was describing something she found hard to tolerate.

The ritual itself came from the Roman Catholic rite of 1614, meant to expel demons through religious authority. By exorcism I mean that organized ritual aimed at an alleged possessing entity, which is different from prayer more generally. Modern Church texts, which wouldn't have governed decisions in 1976, are clear that illness and possession are different things: the Catechism says a major exorcism requires a priest and the bishop's permission and that one must be sure it isn't an illness, and U.S. bishops call for medical and psychiatric assessment first. Taking mental illness seriously doesn't place a person outside a religious worldview, and I don't think this has to be a choice between faith and medical care.

What Were the Sixty-Seven Sessions Actually Like?

When I hear “exorcism,” I picture a single confrontation, the way movies do: someone arrives, something terrifying happens, and it's over. Here the first session wasn't the whole event, and neither was the fifth or the twentieth. At least 67 sessions took place between September 1975 and the eve of her death in 1976, roughly six or seven a month for nearly a year, while her physical health was already a clear concern.

They didn't all happen in one place, either. BR24 reports that they took place at her parents' home and at times in her room at a Würzburg student residence, which overlapped with her university life. A fellow student who lived on her floor, Mechthild Westiner, recalls that Anneliese told her people at home and in Würzburg had talked her into believing she was possessed, that Anneliese herself didn't believe it and wanted a modern, open life, and that the exorcists were introduced to her as doctors.

The accounts of the sessions are distressing. Retrospective reporting in taz describes her screaming and struggling, being held or tied down when she tried to hit or bite, and prayers, holy water, and commands directed at the supposed demons. That is a published account, not a medical report, and I want to be clear about that. But restraint during a ritual deserves serious scrutiny. If someone is agitated enough that others are holding them down, who is assessing their physical condition, and who decides whether this is helping or hurting? Her parents may well have believed they were protecting her from injury. That something is intended to protect someone doesn't make the situation safe.

We also can't soften the whole thing into people quietly praying beside her. Screaming, struggling, restraint, and being repeatedly addressed as though hostile beings were speaking through you would be terrifying, even if I can't say she experienced every session that way.

“Her parents and priests can still believe in possession and call a doctor.”

— Jessica Strohm, Host & Show Creator

What Do the Recordings Actually Tell Us?

Some sessions were recorded, and the recordings became part of the criminal case. Washington Post courtroom reporting from 1978 describes them being played at trial. That gives them several roles: a record of what the priests believed was happening, evidence in a prosecution, and now, for many people, the first thing they hear when they search her name. The recordings make you wonder who or what is speaking. The physical situation makes you ask what is happening to the person producing that voice. Both questions are legitimate, but I don't want the first to drown out the second.

My first reaction to some of the exchanges was that they sounded bizarrely authentic, and I found myself unsettled by how immediate the responses seemed. But a fast response to a question doesn't prove something is real, and I couldn't find a reliable word-for-word translation of the German, so I won't treat any single translated line as established.

An exchange described by Deutschlandfunk Kultur is easier to examine. In the portion it discusses, Renz asks whether it's good for the devil that people no longer believe in him. The answer, from Anneliese or the entity supposedly speaking through her, is yes, because disbelief gives the devil more power. That is a leading question. It begins with an assumption about who is present, and the answer is then framed and interpreted within that assumption. I'm not saying Renz deliberately coached her. I'm saying he was an active participant who chose the questions, decided which answers needed follow-ups, and decided what they meant.

Other researchers have raised the same possibility. In a 2020 article, psychologist Sarah Demmrich summarizes an assessment by Johannes Mischo and Ulrich Niemann, commissioned by the German Bishops' Conference, which concluded that her religious surroundings reinforced her possession symptoms through suggestion. That doesn't explain every word she said, but it gives us a reason to take the priest's role seriously, and it offers a third option beyond the idea that she was either possessed or performing: a seriously unwell person, deeply affected by the way those around her framed what was happening.

Published accounts say the exorcists believed six entities were involved: Lucifer, Judas, Cain, Nero, Hitler, and a deceased priest often named as Valentin Fleischmann. It's a strange list, mixing biblical figures, rulers, a twentieth-century dictator, and a local religious figure, and the question I find most important is how those names came up in the first place. The Fleischmann story is often presented as the hardest detail to explain, the claim that she knew things about a dead priest she couldn't otherwise have known. For that to change my mind I'd need the specific statements, a dependable record of when they were made, verification that they were accurate, and some way of ruling out ordinary sources of that information. I can't find that, so I'm left interested but unconvinced.

What Was Happening to Anneliese Michel's Body?

The recordings leave me unsure what I'm hearing, while the photographs leave me asking where the doctors were. By spring 1976 she had stopped eating, and the religious intervention carried on regardless. Plenty of retellings mention the food refusal, but few explain what made eating so hard or frightening, or what anyone did to keep her alive. Some accounts say she told people the demons wouldn't allow her to eat. For someone who believes the demons are real, driving them out becomes the priority, which I can understand. Still, the body keeps its own clock, and it couldn't wait for the exorcism to work.

By the time she died, Anneliese weighed about 68 pounds, roughly 31 kilograms. Reports describe severe emaciation and bruising on her face, hands, arms, and legs, and taz describes her knees splitting open from repeated, compulsive kneeling. That kneeling is a devotional movement, a genuflection, and accounts describe hundreds of repetitions even as she weakened. TIME reported in 1978 that her parents said she had made 500 deep knee bends in one day shortly before her death, and that they took her endurance as a sign of the devil's power. That count is their statement, not an independent measurement.

That detail changed how I understood the situation. Something I would treat as a reason to get urgent help was read by her parents as support for the possession explanation. I'd have been more worried about what the exertion was doing to her. For context, MedlinePlus lists weakness, tiredness, lightheadedness, frequent illness, and slow-healing wounds among the symptoms of malnutrition, and says treatment includes addressing the underlying cause. These are general medical effects, not findings from her body, but they show why her physical state mattered: a body deprived of nutrition has less capacity to cope with anything else.

On June 30, 1976, the final session took place. Anneliese died the next day. The autopsy reportedly listed severe malnutrition and dehydration, though BR24 notes that she died emaciated of pneumonia. I was tempted at first to separate the cause of death from the exorcisms, as in, technically she died of malnutrition. But that tells us what happened physically and nothing about how her care was allowed to reach that point. A physical cause of death doesn't settle whether other people are responsible for failing to prevent it.

Who Was Held Responsible for Her Death?

Four people were charged: her parents, Anna and Josef Michel, and the priests Ernst Alt and Arnold Renz. The charge was negligent homicide, centered on the failure to obtain medical help. That's not the same as alleging they wanted her dead. They may have believed they were helping her and still failed in a way that made them criminally responsible.

In April 1978, the court in Aschaffenburg convicted all four and sentenced them to six months in prison, suspended on probation. According to TIME, the prosecutor, Karl Stenger, argued that calling a doctor would not have compromised their religious convictions, which is the point I keep returning to. Nobody had to abandon their spiritual worldview to get help for her body. Ney-Hellmuth's conclusion, as she told Deutschlandfunk Kultur, was that Anneliese could have been saved, since medical reports indicated that timely forced feeding and regular medication would have made a normal life possible.

There is a complicating factor I don't want to skip. Anneliese was an adult, and the Würzburg diocese's account of Ney-Hellmuth's research says she and her family refused medical help in favor of a spiritual solution. Her views about her own care matter. At the same time, when someone is severely unwell and refusing treatment, I'd want qualified people to assess what was happening, what she understood, and what help was available, rather than leaving that to people already convinced the answer was an exorcism. That's my view of what should have happened, not a claim about what German law allowed in 1976.

According to Skeptical Inquirer, Renz argued that medical matters weren't the exorcist's responsibility, and the old ritual did direct priests to leave medical treatment to physicians. But leaving treatment to a physician requires there to be a physician, and by then there wasn't one. The result, I think, is a dynamic where the parents rely on the religious authority they've asked for help, the priest assumes feeding and medical appointments belong to the family, and each sees themselves as responsible for one part while assuming someone else is handling the rest. That's speculation about how it might have felt from inside, but it's why assigning responsibility matters. A person in need can't survive on everyone assuming someone else is covering the other half.

Why Did Nobody Change Course?

Bishop Stangl signed off on the rite but never met Anneliese, and BR24 reports that the investigation against him was closed for exactly that reason. The diocese's account says Ney-Hellmuth does not attribute the missing medical oversight to him, while critics faulted his passivity during the trial. Whether or not he was criminally responsible is a separate matter from the broader question of institutional responsibility. Approving something sets consequences in motion even if you're never in the room, and it leaves open who was meant to check whether the intervention was helping or harming. According to TIME, the German Bishops' Conference afterward ruled that exorcisms could proceed only if a doctor was brought in.

The frightening part, to me, is how easily her physical decline could be absorbed into the same explanation that had justified the ritual to begin with. When her parents believed her condition was demonic, her deterioration could be read as confirmation, not as an emergency. I also thought about Ruby Franke, whose case I'm not equating with this one. The Washington County Attorney's Office says religious extremism motivated the abuse of two of her children, which it describes as deprivation and physical abuse the women believed were necessary for repentance and for expelling evil spirits. The narrower connection that interests me is this: if suffering is interpreted as part of a process that will save someone, at what point do the people administering it recognize they're causing harm?

There is a hopeful note in how the Würzburg diocese describes its approach today. In reporting published in June 2026, the diocese's representative says it now holds a detailed initial conversation and offers individual pastoral support through a team that includes an external psychiatrist, and that no priest has been commissioned to perform an exorcism there since Anneliese's case. That doesn't tell us how every religious community handles these situations, but it shows what another approach can look like: a person can be taken seriously when they describe spiritual distress and still meet someone qualified to assess their mental health. I don't see why those forms of support need to undermine each other.

What Might Being “Helped” Have Felt Like? A Personal Reflection

This section is personal, and I want to say so plainly. I was raised without religion and didn't turn toward spirituality until my thirties. A few years ago I read The Hidden Messages in Water by Masaru Emoto, which changed how I think about the energy we put into the world. The book proposes that ice crystals form differently depending on the words and intentions directed at the water, with kind messages producing lovely, orderly shapes and hostile ones producing distorted shapes. I find that idea compelling for myself, but please hear it as a personal belief and not as established science. Experiments on the question, run by Dean Radin together with Emoto and a colleague, reported a modest result under a triple-blind design. Because Emoto's own team took part, though, they aren't an independent replication.

That's the lens I brought to Anneliese. When I think about positive energy, I think about connection and warmth, and about drawing someone toward you; negative energy feels like fear, disgust, hostility, and pushing something away. An exorcism is an attempt to expel something, and the priests believed they were confronting demons. If you believe an evil presence is harming someone you care about, you might feel protective toward them and hostile toward the thing you think is inside them. The problem I keep coming back to is that Anneliese was still there, receiving the experience. I don't know how you aim that intensity at an alleged entity without the person hearing it, feeling it, and living it too. If it were me, being surrounded by people who seemed frightened of what was inside me wouldn't make me feel safer, and I'm aware that this is me imagining her situation, not knowing it.

There's also a more concrete reason to take the emotional atmosphere seriously. NIMH describes stress as a physical and mental response that can affect sleep and the body, and NIH's News in Health reviews research on positive emotions and health, with its own caveats about what that research can show. None of that validates an energy mechanism, and I'm not suggesting positive energy would have cured Anneliese or that negative energy caused her death. I'm wondering what a repeated experience like this might have added to an already stressful situation on top of a pre-existing illness.

How Much Room Does a Belief Get?

This is where I think Anneliese's story speaks to all of us, through the idea of an overvalued idea. Definitions vary, and the term has its own clinical history, but psychiatrist David Veale's 2002 analysis puts it clearly: an idea becomes overvalued when the values behind it grow so central that they shape a person's identity, and are held so inflexibly that the person can't adjust, even when acting on the idea does damage. The trap is attachment. When questioning a belief begins to feel like questioning yourself, reconsidering it feels like a threat. Someone who sees herself as spiritually intuitive may hear a request to rethink a spiritual explanation as an attack on who she is. I try not to let that feeling decide what I'm willing to hear.

People are entitled to different belief systems, and I wouldn't want everyone to think like me. The risk appears when a belief grows large enough that it crowds out everything else. By most accounts, that is what happened around Anneliese: her parents and priests were so sure of possession that her worsening health kept being filed under the spiritual. What I take from this is a habit worth practicing, which is noticing when something doesn't fit the explanation we've settled on, especially when another person bears the consequences. Believing in energy doesn't stop me from questioning a claim about energy, and believing in prayer doesn't stop anyone from recognizing when medicine is needed. There's room for both.

Telling ourselves we're open-minded is easy. Taking other possibilities seriously when they challenge our own worldview is the hard part.

When it comes to what we believe, do we give other explanations the same consideration we give our own?

Diagnostic Research Themes
Overvalued IdeasDiffusion of ResponsibilitySuggestibilityInterpretation of PsychosisStress and Wellbeing
Verified Archives & Documentation

Sources & Further Reading

Case History and Reporting

Medical Context (Modern Guidance)

Church Guidance (Modern)

  • Vatican

    The current distinction between illness and possession and the requirement for a bishop's permission. It did not govern the 1976 decision.

  • United States Conference of Catholic Bishops

    Current U.S. guidance calling for medical, psychological, and psychiatric assessment before referral to an exorcist. It is not the historical German standard.

Psychology and Belief

Comparison and Personal Reflection

More From Pretty Evil

Keep Inquiring

Related Enquiries

Fraternity Hazing: Dying to Belong
Hive MindEP11

Fraternity Hazing: Dying to Belong

Stone Foltz, Timothy Piazza, Michael Deng and George Desdunes died in cases involving fraternity hazing, each under very different circumstances. What connects them is a harder question: what happens to our sense of right and wrong when belonging, tradition and group loyalty make dangerous behavior feel normal?

Belle Gibson: 'Trust Me, I'm Dying'
Pretty EvilEP10

Belle Gibson: 'Trust Me, I'm Dying'

Belle Gibson had the kind of cancer story people desperately wanted to believe. She said she'd been diagnosed with terminal brain cancer and given months to live. Instead of accepting that prognosis, she changed the way she ate, turned to alternative therapies, and somehow survived. There was just one fairly significant problem: Belle Gibson had never had cancer.